This photograph was taken in Oregon, near Grants Pass, in 1939. The woman works as a hops picker, and is purchasing supplies at the "Company Store". On the morning the photograph was taken, the woman made 42 cents. She spends the earnings at the store, and buys one pound of bologna, a package of cigarettes and a small pastry. I worry we have forgotten just how tough things were back in the Great Depression.Sunday, September 28, 2008
Company Store
This photograph was taken in Oregon, near Grants Pass, in 1939. The woman works as a hops picker, and is purchasing supplies at the "Company Store". On the morning the photograph was taken, the woman made 42 cents. She spends the earnings at the store, and buys one pound of bologna, a package of cigarettes and a small pastry. I worry we have forgotten just how tough things were back in the Great Depression.It looks like we have made it through another week without a complete collapse of our financial institutions. Even with this, I saw that another one of the largest banks, Washington Mutual, went under. From news reports, I wonder if Wachovia will make it through this upcoming week or if it will be the next bank to fail.
After a lot of consideration, I have actually decided that I am against the bailout plan that they are trying to push through. I fully realize that the $700 Billion bailout is needed in order to avoid a financial meltdown, but as I see it, it just pushes out the inevitable. The whole problem has been too much money. Executives who do a poor job getting tens of millions of dollars per year in compensation. People who can not afford a home being given "Jumbo" loans, and purchasing homes well beyond what they can afford. People who should be saving continuing to borrow money against the appreciating value of their home in order to fuel an excessive lifestyle. We got into this mess because of greed, excess money, and excess credit. The last thing we need to do is to throw more money into the system to try and keep fundamentally bad behavior going. What we need to do is to all spend less, give more, and save more. A financial meltdown could encourage all of us to live more financially responsibly.
Folks, we need to spend less. Here are some simple points for your consideration.
1) As a child, Abraham Lincoln was not in the Youth Soccer Program, and his mother did not have a big SUV. He turned out OK, and in fact accomplished a great deal.
2) As a child, Teddy Roosevelt did not have a cell phone. He did OK as well.
3) When Martin Luther King was a boy, he did not have Cable TV in the home. This did not slow him down at all.
4) I am pretty sure that George Patton did not have an Xbox 360 as a boy.
5) Charles Dickens grew up in a home that did not have a 60 inch plasma TV.
6) Booker T. Washington never had an iPhone.
7) When Neil Armstrong became a Junior in High School, his parents did not buy him a new Ford Mustang.
8) Sam Houston never played golf.
9) Jim Thorpe never wore a pair of Nike shoes.
10) Clara Barton never paid for a manicure.
Folks we are spending too much money on things that don't matter. It is time to tighten our belts, and refocus on the things that do matter . . . faith, family, and friends.
Labels:
Great Depression
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
![[dan-truett-mcwhorter.jpg]](http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_473nrD5vEv8/S5hAR2x0JVI/AAAAAAAACVo/caHZJMX-j9o/s400/dan-truett-mcwhorter.jpg)

Boy, I am sure glad I am not your kid.
ReplyDeleteWhat anon #1 neglects to realize, is that people in other countries do with a lot less and not only make do with what they have without the massive debt we do, but are actually happier.
ReplyDeleteMakes sense to me.
Nice post, Thanks! CM
anon #2
ReplyDeleteOh really?
Rampant consumerism annoys me too but the idea that poor people are somehow happier is ridiculous. (I'm from Hungary.)
I love your view and you give food for thought! I think that we should all live within our means. By that I am saying that if you can afford to get your kids a cell phone AND still eat and pay your bills, then go ahead! I think part of the problem is that people do spend way to much money on STUFF and FLUFF and then it puts them in a bind when the bills are due. I have been poor before. I am talking no food, no gas in the car etc. Now I am in a bit of a better place. I wasnt happy being broke, I am not overly happy having some money in the bank (although it is MUCH better than the alternative)I think what your trying to say is that we should all evaluate what we can do without. I totally agree that it is out of control. I am totally guilty. I just bought my 3 year old grandson a 45 dollar Dallas Cowboys football jersy. Did he need it? NO would I have spent that much money on myself? Probably not, do I still get to eat this week and put gas in my car? Yes. I really appriciate your insights. I agree that we have so much STUFF in our life, that the PEOPLE get left out. Thank you for giving me a chance to think about things a differnt way.
ReplyDeleteMom
I guess where I diverge from your thinking is that I should give up the luxuries that I can afford, so that the top one percent can have even more luxuries. You cited the failure of Washington Mutual. Are you aware that the CEO of WaMu had been on the job for 17 DAYS and was awarded a Golden Parachute of $19 MILLION! Yes, he got more than One Million Dollars a day to ride the last ride. For this I should give up my plasma TV?
ReplyDeleteIf they close up the school where you just started to teach, what do you think your Golden Parachute will look like?
I will have to disagree with you PJM to an extent. I resent that the government is having to step in and bail out so many money institutions, but I look at the good side by realizing that much of the money will be returned to the people when the saved banks, etc. are made whole and prosper again. I look at the proposed plan as an investment in the American economy that will, over time, return the buyout money with interest.
ReplyDeleteWe got here due to the lack of attention by the federal regulators and the greed of the investment houses, bankers, real estate businesses, sellers and buyers as a group. Each part of the above group wanted its piece of the pie and as long as everyone got their piece, no one was unhappy enough to raise a flag to the federal regulators who were asleep at the wheel or, worse, criminally involved.
That said, I think we must pass the bailout to avoid becoming even weaker in the worldwide financial markets, but the real question is will the bill actually "cure" whe whole patient. By that I mean will it provide better scrutiny of the banks and assure that the CEO, COO and other executives are not rewarded for incompetancy? There is a concerted bipartisan effort to get this bill out, but I hope they put enough safeguards in to prevent it happening again.
I don't need another full
1930's depression and, from what my parents have told me, neither does anyone else.
anon # 1
ReplyDeleteOf course, not everyone poor is happy, on that I will concur.
Yet, not having an oversized house (full of stuff you really don't need) or a huge SUV (you really don't need in a city) or many other things, not to mention not having a whole lot of debt, certainly makes others around the world happier than we are, since they do not have to work, simply to get all those things.
That's all I was sayin'.....
Somehow, after so many years working I am now making less, but have more (and not more things). Sadly, not because I want it that way, but I'm learning that not having and wasting things, makes for a lighter life and world, that's all.
It wasn't a personal attack! ; )
You are right to a great degree. I teach 1st through 4th graders and see it every day at school, although the problem I see is a little different. Kids being dropped off at school in a big SUV by parents who have no visible means of support. The kids are on free lunch, yet have money in their pocket to spend on everything that comes along at school. If the kids who pay for lunch get behind and don't pay for 3 days, they are presented with a peanut butter sandwich in a brown paper sack at lunch while the "free lunchers" get baked chicken or whatever we're having. There's not a thing wrong with peanut butter sandwiches, or the free lunch kids getting a good lunch - but you get the picture. There are certainly families who need help, but there seems to be trouble at both ends of the food chain here. In my part of the world, we have many welfare families that are given the money, food stamps, housing, etc. while they use the money they do make to buy expensive clothes and vehicles. Your web-site is a breath of fresh air. S.M.A.
ReplyDeleteBuy every dodad and fluffball you want. Live in a mansion, drive what you want, and spoil your kids rotten. Have a ball.
ReplyDeleteJust don't BORROW the money to do it.
Bruce,
ReplyDeleteThank you for your post . . . actually you say it very well, and it was what I was trying to say. I am not against all the gadgets, just that people are going in debt to buy them.
PJM
Having worked myself out of debt that I alone created, I appreciate paying for something with cash and knowing that is the end of the transaction. We save up for large purchases and the only debt we have is our mortgage and one car loan. Each month we pay all our bills in full. The stress I carry now is from raising my family, not from wondering where the next credit card payment is going to come from. It's a much better thing to worry about!
ReplyDeleteThe ultimate goal then, is to get everyone in the country to live within their means. But how do you do that, you may ask?
ReplyDeleteThe way to fix all of these financial problems is not to pump more cash into the fray, these problems are born out of a society that says "you NEED to buy this." This to say that giving people more money without any guidance or education of any kind will only provide them with the means to buy in deeper to this buy, buy, buy culture/financial death trap.
So the problem becomes that people - particularly younger people - don't know how to live within their means. The solution, then, is education. students need to be educated in the art, as well as the science, of living within your means and stretching your dollar, instead of just borrowing more. Education at the secondary level will resolve these problems completely. Granted, it is not the quick fix that everyone is looking for, but, as we all know, quick fixes are not the way to get things done.
Furthurmore, the bailout plan is one of the worst ideas I have ever heard. Granted, I only posses a cursory knowledge of the workings of wall street but it just makes no sense. Being that I am a keen observer of the world around me I can see trends, and cycles and what not, and what I see now is a natural cycle being halted by ignorance.
I fear for our future as a country.
Finally, I would like to say that I agree with bruce to some degree But I just wanted to leave off with two quotes that have been my sort of financial philosophy.
"... to be simple is to be great." - Emerson
"...money can't buy me love." - The Beatles
-SB
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteI just found your blog and think it's great. Where do you find your photos? Are they all in the public domain?
ReplyDeleteI think it is telling that you list cites no current examples of folks rising to greatness. I find it telling that those that HAVE these things (and the money) generate (and use) a true advantage over those that cannot. I fear there may be a far more horrific truth below the surface here: that those that do not HAVE, also cannot BE. The social strata of this country seem to be "rigid-ising"; the poorest no longer have a road upward and those that can possibly afford to give their children the opportunities are doing everything they can to make sure they do not slide down the scale - even though it is an unconscious decision.
ReplyDeleteAs a counterpoint to my own argument, though, I would present the case of Neil deGrasse Tyson. I hope his story (among others) prove my fears to be ill-founded.
This is for the first poster who said "I am sure glad I am not your kid."
ReplyDeletePeople didn't have CATV, the Internet, PS2s, Nikes, plasma screen TVs, McDonalds, air conditioning or SUV's 100 or 200 years ago. They didn't even have antibiotics. Tell me, how in the world did they ever survive. Obviously the did, or we all wouldn't be here.
You can live without if you need to. The problem is, that our society today, and the current generation (the 20-30 year olds), only know wealth and the gimme, gimme, gimme NOW mentality. And that even means, extending their credit to the point where they can't pay their bills. I'd rather have something that is paid for with cash, knowing that I will not lose it than having something nicer and loosing it because I can't pay for it in the long run.
If I want something, and I can't afford it now, I save up for it. Not take out a new credit card.
I'm so sorry that you have to buy cheaper clothing. I'm so sorry that you might have to buy whatever you have cash for. I'm sorry that you are a spoiled rotten brat who has no clue on how expensive you really are to your parents. If you want something, get a job and pay for it yourself.
I am 40 years old, and have NEVER had a credit card and have only had 1 loan in my life. And that was for my first car 20 years ago. I've paid cash since then. No I don't own a house, but that is my choice, not by not being able to afford it.
I have very little worries about how I am going to pay my rent, my electric, my gas, my phone, and my car insurance next month, because I planned and live within my means.
HELLO! My name is reality. I KNOW we haven't met.
I have heard the average american has $4K in savings. The reason this is so low, if true, is an addiction to credit. If the market is not free to go down when credit ends, then we are setting ourselves up for more pain later, IMHO.
ReplyDeleteThanks to the Senate, this Great Depression will make the last one look like a Sunday School Picnic.
ReplyDeleteTheir bailout will cause a hyper inflationary depression, where dollars could be weighed by the pound.
In Germany an egg could pay off a farm. A hot dog a wheelbarrow full of marcs.
Lots of superfluous stuff you mentioned, and I totally agree. The headache is, many people all over the world are employed in the manufacturing and distribution of these things that advertising tells us are must-haves, and those people (many of whom can't even buy them) need the money they earn with them to buy those things everyone really needs: food, clothing, shelter. It would be a good thing if society concentrated on the manufacture of those goods that are really necessary, but that would mean less jobs. Unless we find a way to make everybody work just his share needed, which would be a couple of hours a day, probably less, ans still pay everybody enough to buy the necessary things for a life in dignity. Many people would say this is some kind of communism, but I say it's American. There would be no need to touch private ownership of business and entrpreneurship, it would just mean to better direct that level or organisation that already exists in our economy.
ReplyDeleteI'm sure all those people had the equivalents of those luxuries in their day, though.
ReplyDeleteI didn't have an iPod when I was little, but I did have a Walkman. Same difference.
Did you notice you only found one woman who "did okay" without something, and that something was ... a manicure? Is that the best example you could come up with?
ReplyDeleteRecessions and depressions affect women in numerous and difficult ways, not least because in the beginning, stimulus money goes to "men's" jobs such as building and construction.
And young girls' main pastime, I daresay, is NOT "(getting) manicure(s)."
I think this is a very nice site you have here and I totally agree with your point on waste and garbage that is not needed yet to some, can't seem to see life's bigger picture and the joys they can bring. I think this stuff is a replacement to some to replace the human contact previously important in society. The I-Pod or PS2 is the "new best friend" since at times, it's not even safe for kids to walk to their friends house alone anymore.
ReplyDeleteAnyway, thanks for this fantastic site.
Best
Stu